New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Friday upheld the acquittal of Peepli Live co-director Mahmood Farooqui in a rape case.
The SC dismissed the plea of the woman, a US citizen, against Farooqui’s acquittal by the Delhi High Court in September 2017.
“It is a hard case but has been extremely well decided by the Delhi High Court. This is a case where the woman and Farooqui were in a relationship,” the apex court said.
The court also said the woman “wrote an email saying ‘I do love you’ after the incident.
The Delhi HC had aside the trial court order awarding h Farroqui seven years jail term for allegedly raping a US researcher. The court directed that Farooqi, who is presently in jail, be released forthwith.
The HC raised doubts over the veracity of the incident and the complaint and took note of the fact that there was delay by the victim in filing the FIR. The court also questioned if there was consent or not. It also raised the question on whether the accused understood that there was no consent.
The court made some controversial observations and said that the woman’s no may have in fact meant a yes. “Instances of woman behaviour are not unknown that a feeble ‘no’ may mean a ‘yes’,” the court said.
It further said that in cases where the two parties are known to each other and have had physical relations, it would be “really difficult to decipher whether little or no resistance and a feeble ‘no’ was actually a denial of consent.”
The court also said that the woman had feigned an orgasm to end the ordeal and this may have given the accused the wrong impression that she was “okay with it and has participated in the act.” “The appellant had no opportunity to know that there was an element of fear in the mind of the prosecutrix forcing her to go along,” it said.
On July 30, 2016, a fast track court had held Farooqui guilty of rape and had stated that the statement of the victim was of "sterling quality" with no embellishments or improvements. The fast-track court also concluded that the testimony of the victim was truthful and supports the conviction of the accused.
The woman, a student at the Columbia University in New York, had told the police that she was raped by Farooqui at his Sukhdev Vihar residence in Delhi on March 28, 2015.
The two were at a party and Farooqui had reportedly gotten drunk and taken her to a different room in the house and forced himself on her.
The woman met Farooqui in Varanasi where she had gone to collect information. Farooqui was helping her with her research work.
Farooqui directed 'Peepli Live' with his wife, Anusha Rizvi. The film was released in 2010.
Comments
0 comment